The advance notice sketches a new class of exchange that would list the crypto asset itself rather than a contract on it, with trades intermediated by a futures commission merchant and leverage supplied by registered providers. Lawyers reading it say the document contradicts itself on what counts as actual delivery.
The proposed paragraph names sports, politics, cultural and weather events, and a companion interim final rule issued the same day puts casino-style gambling outside the definition. The agency adopts the Third Circuit's reasoning and argues against the Ninth and Sixth Circuits, in a dispute the Supreme Court has been asked to settle.
Neither proposal was ever finalized, so the withdrawals leave current obligations for banks and money services businesses unchanged. FinCEN said it still believes illicit actors use mixers and may return to the subject.
An adviser could hold client crypto itself only after determining in writing, and again every quarter, that no permitted custodian is available for that asset. Transactions would need two people to authorize them, and the comment period runs 60 days from Federal Register publication.
RIN 3038-AF80 arrived at OIRA on September 17 under a title naming two regulations, crypto asset transactions and crypto asset markets. The rule has never appeared in a Unified Agenda, so no abstract, timetable or text exists publicly.
The rewrite starts a fresh rulemaking after the agency withdrew its 2023 safeguarding proposal. Until then, US institutional crypto custody runs on a staff letter with no legal force.
Approval opens a comment period on Paul Atkins's three-track proposal: a startup exemption, a fundraising exemption, and a safe harbor that ends investment-contract treatment once network development is complete. Compliance-relevant adoption is a 2027 story.