The order from the Abu Dhabi Global Market Courts names no defendants, so Binance's lawyers have attached a list of 26,000 wallet addresses they say hold stolen funds. The order has not been published, and Reuters reported the announcement without the amount.
Binance said on Wednesday that it has obtained a worldwide freezing order from the Abu Dhabi Global Market Courts covering $6.5 billion, directed at the people it accuses of taking about $6.34 billion out of its hot wallets on October 29. The exchange said Justice William Stone SBS KC issued the order against defendants it has not identified.
The order covers more than the exchange says it lost. Binance has put the October 29 loss at about $6.34 billion, traced to a tampered installer an engineer downloaded in June and an intrusion that reached its internal wallet signing service four months later. Against the $6.5 billion in the order, that leaves a difference of roughly $160 million, and the accounts of Wednesday's announcement do not say what it represents.
An order against people nobody can name works through the assets a court can describe. Binance said its lawyers have assembled a list of 26,000 wallet addresses they believe hold stolen funds, and that the list will be updated as the money moves. M. Kendall Day of Gibson Dunn, the firm representing Binance, called it a living list and described the injunction as “one of, if not the, largest publicly known freezing orders ever made.”
The exchange said it also obtained interim orders over specific stolen assets and orders requiring assets to be handed over. Some of those interim orders name defendants that have already frozen stolen funds, and Binance said it is not alleging wrongdoing by those parties. Dugan Bliss, the exchange's deputy general counsel, said Binance will “continue using every lawful tool available to trace, freeze and recover stolen assets.”
The practical point of a court order at this stage is to give the companies already sitting on frozen money a reason to release it. About $2.85 billion of the roughly $6.34 billion affected has been frozen or intercepted, about 45 percent of the total. Most of that is stablecoin. Tether has reported freezing more than $1.5 billion of USDT and Circle about $1.1 billion of USDC, and those are issuer decisions rather than transfers: the tokens sit where they are until someone with authority says otherwise. Binance said some issuers and exchanges want a court order before releasing frozen funds, and that the ADGM orders can be served over the blockchain.
Tom Robinson of Elliptic told The Block's newsletter earlier this month that frozen stablecoins could be reissued to Binance, but that issuers would first want “a clear legal basis.” He estimated that about $3.3 billion of the stolen bitcoin, ether and XRP is beyond anyone's reach, because those assets have no issuer who can freeze a balance. “Each time the funds move, there is a chance to catch them,” he said.
The ADGM order is not the first legal step taken over the October theft. The US Justice Department said last week that it had obtained court authorization to seize or restrain more than $1.2 billion of the assets taken from Binance, an authorization that covers holding the money rather than returning it. No one has been charged.
Who may instruct a stablecoin issuer to hold or release a balance is being contested elsewhere. Conduit Technology asked a US federal judge in October to rule that Tether had no right to freeze $2.76 million of its USDT, to order the tokens released and to award damages.
Binance has said the loss does not threaten the business. SB Seker, who runs the exchange's Asia-Pacific operations, said the cost of replacing the stolen tokens was statistically not large, and that “we can take the impact and we can weather it without any change to the way we operate.”
The order itself has not been published. The ADGM Courts have issued no announcement about it, and the jurisdiction's regulator, the Financial Services Regulatory Authority, last addressed the incident in a statement on October 30. Reuters reported the exchange's announcement on Wednesday without the $6.5 billion figure, which comes from the statement Binance gave The Block. Neither account gives the date the order was issued.