Markets
BTC— —
ETH— —
SOL— —
XRP— —
BNB— —
ADA— —
DOGE— —
MCap— —
BTC— —
ETH— —
SOL— —
XRP— —
BNB— —
ADA— —
DOGE— —
MCap— —
Markets

Chainflip Says $12 Million Left Its Vaults, Most of It Bitcoin

The Block's Saturday report put the loss at $4.86 million and said the Bitcoin vault looked untouched. Chainflip Labs' own tally names 122.86 bitcoin, and the attacker has until 18:38 UTC on November 23 to return 90% of the funds.

By MiningPool Staff··4 min read
Chainflip Says $12 Million Left Its Vaults, Most of It Bitcoin

Key Points

  • The Block's Saturday report put the loss at $4.86 million and said the Bitcoin vault looked untouched.
  • Chainflip Labs' own tally names 122.86 bitcoin, and the attacker has until 18:38 UTC on November 23 to return 90% of the funds.

Chainflip Labs has put the loss from Saturday's attack on its cross-chain swap protocol at about $12 million and named the assets taken: 122.86 bitcoin, 520.22 ether, 3.25 million USDC and 758,141 USDT. In a statement addressed to the attacker, reported by Cointelegraph, the company offered a 10% bounty for the return of the remaining 90% by 18:38 UTC on November 23. It said it would treat a return before that deadline as a white-hat recovery and withdraw its reports and complaints to law enforcement.

That tally is about two and a half times the figure in the first account of the drain. The Block reported at 15:23 UTC on Saturday that roughly $4.86 million in ether and stablecoins had left the Ethereum vault, and that the Bitcoin and Solana vaults were apparently unaffected. The bitcoin Chainflip has since counted is worth about $7.5 million at the $61,200 a coin CoinGecko showed at 16:24 UTC on Sunday, which is more than that entire earlier figure.

Two of the four legs can be read directly on Ethereum. Transaction 0xc928950f succeeded in block 26461896 at 07:10:59 UTC on Saturday and moved 3,249,631.41 USDC and 758,141.33 USDT out of the vault contract at 0xf5e10380 to a single address. Both match the figures Chainflip gave, the USDT leg to the dollar. The account that sent the transaction, 0x78fa4ac2, was making its first transaction, matching reports that the attacker worked from a fresh wallet. The 520.22 ether is not recorded as a token transfer and cannot be read from a public node without archival access, so that leg rests on Chainflip's own statement and on the alert from security firm Decurity that The Block cited.

Advertisement

728×90

The attack did not turn on a contract bug, according to the firms that have examined it. The Decurity alert said the attacker had apparently obtained the aggregate signing key that controls the vaults. The Block, reading Chainflip's documentation, describes a scheme in which 150 validators jointly hold that key, 100 of them must take part in any signature, no single validator holds the whole thing, and the key rotates every three days, most recently on November 18. A signature that key produces is valid to the vault contracts whether or not the validators meant to produce it, which separates this case from the bridge bug that cost NEAR Intents about $3.8 million and puts it nearer the dispute in which BitGo said Unocoin's own keys had signed the transfers its customer disputed.

The signature itself looked wrong in one respect. Blockchain data firm Bitquery, whose on-chain work has traced stolen funds before, found, in an investigation The Block cited, that the withdrawal carried a 39-digit nonce where neighboring legitimate withdrawals sat around 315,000, and called it the only break in sequence among 299,677 signatures since 2023. Bitquery also noted that the aggregate key changed about an hour and three quarters after the theft, and said the timing alone establishes nothing.

Chainflip's statement traces the preparation to Tornado Cash funding on November 11 and a validator account registered on November 20. AMLBot, quoted in the same report, said nearly all the proceeds went back through Tornado Cash and that the laundering ran with high-speed automation, quickly enough that Circle and Tether could not freeze the stablecoins. Chainflip says it holds identifying information on the validator and the servers used.

The bitcoin is the part no public account traces. The Block flagged a transfer of about 10.5 bitcoin out of a Chainflip vault address roughly two hours after the protocol paused, and said its purpose was unconfirmed. That transaction confirmed in block 976894 at 11:24:18 UTC on Saturday and sent 10.48283731 bitcoin to one new address, which still holds all of it and has spent nothing. The sending address has handled 165,597 bitcoin across 1,845 transactions and now holds none. That movement does not account for the 122.86 bitcoin Chainflip has counted, and no source read for this article identifies the transactions that do.

Applying Sunday's 16:24 UTC prices of $61,200 for bitcoin and $1,718.54 for ether, and taking the stablecoins at par, the four amounts come to about $12.42 million, of which the bitcoin is close to 60%. On those prices the bounty is worth roughly $1.24 million. Bitcoin traded lower on Saturday, when it was coming off a two-year low, so the dollar value at the time of the drain was smaller than that.

Chainflip said on X, as quoted by The Block, that the protocol was going into full safe mode with deposits, withdrawals, swaps and quoting disabled. At about 16:20 UTC on Sunday its website still carried a banner saying services are temporarily unavailable, and the newest entry on its blog, dated November 21, is a guide comparing ways to move USDT between chains. There is no incident post or post-mortem there, and its status page returns no readable content without JavaScript.

The company has not said whether it will cover the loss. After a September 12 exploit that double-processed six Tron withdrawals and cost about $736,000, validators voted to make the affected USDT liquidity providers whole out of surplus funds. This time Chainflip says only that it has identified the mechanism behind the key exposure and taken steps against a repeat. Its FLIP token traded at $0.296 on Sunday afternoon with a market capitalization of $25.0 million, against the roughly $41.6 million The Block recorded before Saturday's fall.

MiningPool content is intended for information and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice.

Advertisement

728×90

Related Stories

Bitcoin's Two-Year Low Put It $31,000 Below JPMorgan's Cost Estimate
Markets

Coinglass counted $2.40 billion of futures liquidations in the 24 hours to 04:16 UTC, and the price was back above $60,000 by 14:39 UTC. JPMorgan's analysts say the gap could narrow as hashrate leaves the network and difficulty adjusts, which is what the November 14 retarget already did.

·MiningPool Staff
BTCS Sold Ether Below Cost to Protect a $64 Million Aave Loan
Markets

The Nasdaq-listed treasury company's 46,676 ether of collateral becomes eligible for automatic partial liquidation at about $1,717 a coin. Ether traded roughly 11% above that level on Friday, and the company's cash balance was $463,000 at the end of September.

·MiningPool Staff
Almost All of BitMine's $6.3 Billion Loss Was Unrealized
Business

BitMine reported $124.8 million of revenue for the year to August 31, and staking and validation supplied $121.4 million of it. Total liabilities were $33.7 million against $15.4 billion of assets, so the loss tracks ether's 44% fall over the year rather than any borrowing.

·MiningPool Staff
Korea Will Let Exchanges Freeze Funds Before a Hack Is Confirmed
Policy

The Financial Services Commission has only decided to issue the no-action letter, and has not published the conditions attached to it or set a date. Current law lets an exchange block withdrawals only once a hack has clearly occurred, which is the gap GOPAX fell into when it froze on an emailed threat on November 6.

·MiningPool Staff

Stay informed

Verifiable crypto journalism, delivered to your inbox.

Weekday mornings. No hype. No financial advice. Just what happened and why it matters.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy.