Markets
BTC— —
ETH— —
SOL— —
XRP— —
BNB— —
ADA— —
DOGE— —
MCap— —
BTC— —
ETH— —
SOL— —
XRP— —
BNB— —
ADA— —
DOGE— —
MCap— —
Policy

Wisconsin Sues Kalshi, Coinbase, Polymarket, Robinhood and Crypto.com, Calling Their Prediction Markets Illegal Sports Betting

Wisconsin's attorney general filed three lawsuits arguing prediction market contracts are illegal sports bets, escalating a jurisdictional battle between states and the CFTC that is almost certainly headed to the Supreme Court.

By Sarah Blake··3 min read
Wisconsin Sues Kalshi, Coinbase, Polymarket, Robinhood and Crypto.com, Calling Their Prediction Markets Illegal Sports Betting

Key Points

  • Wisconsin's attorney general filed three lawsuits arguing prediction market contracts are illegal sports bets, escalating a jurisdictional battle between states and the CFTC that is almost certainly headed to the Supreme Court.

Wisconsin's attorney general filed three lawsuits on 23 April against Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase, Robinhood and Crypto.com, arguing that their prediction market contracts are illegal sports bets under state law and demanding they stop serving Wisconsin residents immediately.

Attorney General Josh Kaul's complaints, filed in Dane County court, target what regulators have long suspected but few have been willing to test: whether event contracts that let users wager on the outcome of an NBA playoff game or an NCAA tournament bracket are financial instruments or simply gambling dressed in fintech language. The complaints describe Wisconsin residents placing bets on which team would win a Final Four matchup, which would cover the point spread, and which would be first to score ten points.

The answer has enormous consequences. If prediction markets are swaps — as Kalshi has argued, and as a Third Circuit ruling earlier this month appeared to support — they fall under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's exclusive federal jurisdiction. If they are bets, they fall under state gambling laws, and states like Wisconsin, where commercial sports betting is illegal outside tribal compacts, can shut them down entirely.

Advertisement

728×90

Kaul's office isn't being subtle about which side it's on. The filings emphasise that platforms collect transaction fees on every contract, likening the model to a casino taking a cut from the house floor. The three suits divide the defendants into logical groupings: one pulls in Kalshi alongside distribution partners Robinhood and Coinbase, which list Kalshi's event contracts on their platforms and take a commission; a second targets Polymarket directly; a third names Crypto.com.

Wisconsin isn't acting alone. New York's attorney general has called each contract 'a bet' in her own proceedings. Arizona has filed suit. Connecticut and Illinois have taken action. But the CFTC itself has pushed back — on 3 April, the commission sued Connecticut, Arizona and Illinois directly, arguing that federal jurisdiction pre-empts state gambling laws and that a 'fragmented patchwork of state regulations' is exactly what Congress rejected when it created the CFTC's mandate.

It's an unusual posture — a federal regulator going to court to protect the companies it oversees from state enforcement, rather than pursuing them itself. The CFTC's chairman declared that the agency would 'safeguard its exclusive regulatory authority over these markets,' a statement that reads less like neutral oversight and more like choosing a side.

The companies' legal teams have staked out their ground. Coinbase's chief legal officer, Paul Grewal, argued that Congress intended prediction and derivatives markets to be regulated nationally through the CFTC, not state-by-state. Kalshi pointed to the Third Circuit's April decision, which treated the CFTC's choice not to block its contracts as a tacit endorsement. That interpretation is contested — the CFTC declined to block the contracts under the previous administration, and the current commission's willingness to defend that inaction against states is a separate, politically charged decision.

For Coinbase and Robinhood, the exposure extends beyond prediction markets. Both distribute Kalshi's contracts as intermediaries, meaning a finding that those contracts constitute gambling could classify them as operators of unlicensed gambling platforms. Several states attach criminal penalties to that classification, not just civil fines. The SEC and CFTC have spent the past year trying to draw clearer jurisdictional lines between their respective domains; Wisconsin's suits threaten to add a third layer of authority — state gaming commissions — to an already crowded regulatory map.

The case is almost certainly Supreme Court-bound. The question of whether the CFTC's jurisdiction over event contracts pre-empts state gambling laws has no definitive federal answer. The Third Circuit gave Kalshi a favourable reading, but it addressed the CFTC's authority, not the states'. No circuit has ruled directly on pre-emption itself.

The practical stakes are substantial. Prediction markets grew rapidly through the 2024 election cycle and haven't slowed since. Kraken's recent $550 million acquisition of Bitnomial shows the scale of institutional capital flowing into CFTC-regulated derivatives infrastructure. A ruling that subjects these platforms to 50 different sets of state gambling laws — each with its own licensing regime, prohibited categories and consumer protections — would fundamentally alter the economics of the industry.

Wisconsin's constitution bans lotteries and most forms of commercial betting outside tribal casinos. Three lawsuits, five defendants, and a question that only the Supreme Court can settle.

MiningPool content is intended for information and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice.

Advertisement

728×90

Related Stories

The SEC's 348 Enforcement Actions Come Without a Crypto Count
Policy

The agency's annual results describe an alleged $95.6 million fraud by the founder of a bitcoin mining business, and three purported crypto platforms and four investment clubs accused of taking at least $14 million, without naming any of them. American Banker, comparing the totals with fiscal 2025, put the overall decline at nearly 24%.

·MiningPool Staff
The White House Nominated Two CLARITY Act Negotiators to the CFTC
Policy

Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland both worked on the market structure bill that fell eleven votes short of a Senate debate in September. The same notice sends Kristin Johnson, a former CFTC commissioner, to Caroline Crenshaw's SEC seat and Steven Levine to Hester Peirce's.

·MiningPool Staff
The DOJ Can Now Seize or Hold $1.2 Billion Taken From Binance
Policy

The Justice Department's announcement covers court authorization rather than a completed forfeiture, and it does not say how much of the $1.2 billion is seized and how much is only restrained. No one has been charged, and the release says nothing about who would receive the money.

·MiningPool Staff
The SEC Backed the CFTC Without Saying What Stock Perps Are
Policy

Its amicus brief rejects the picture of a CFTC gone rogue and an SEC gone missing, but takes no position on whether a perpetual future on one stock is a security future or a security-based swap. The judge who refused to halt the contracts had already leaned the other way on that question.

·MiningPool Staff
Coinbase, Kalshi and Jump Backed the CFTC on Single-Stock Perps
Policy

Their brief argues that a security future cannot be a swap, so the only question is whether equity perpetuals are security futures. It also states that the contracts are now trading, a week after a clearance that named no exchange and no start date.

·MiningPool Staff
FinCEN Ordered US Financial Firms to Stop Moving Funds for MEXC
Policy

The order finds MEXC Global a primary money laundering concern in connection with Russian illicit finance, citing about $16.7 billion in flows FinCEN links to sanctions evasion, Iranian exchangers and cybercrime. It takes effect 30 days after Federal Register publication, which had not happened as of Friday evening.

·MiningPool Staff

Stay informed

Verifiable crypto journalism, delivered to your inbox.

Weekday mornings. No hype. No financial advice. Just what happened and why it matters.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy.